Blue Jays Remove Anthony Santander from ALCS Roster, Ends Season

UPDATE: The Toronto Blue Jays have officially removed designated hitter Anthony Santander from their American League Championship Series (ALCS) roster due to injury, ending his season, the team confirmed on Thursday. This critical decision follows Santander’s ongoing struggles with back issues, making him ineligible for the upcoming World Series should the Jays advance.

In a significant roster change, outfielder Joey Loperfido has been called up to replace Santander. Loperfido has shown promise during the regular season, boasting a strong batting average of .333 across 104 plate appearances. Santander’s injury woes have plagued his performance throughout the 2025 season, where he recorded a disappointing .175 batting average, hitting just six home runs in 54 games.

The announcement comes as the Blue Jays trail 2-1 in the ALCS against the Seattle Mariners, with Game 4 set to take place tonight, October 19, 2025. This pivotal match could decide the team’s fate in the postseason, heightening the urgency of Santander’s absence.

Blue Jays manager John Schneider addressed the media, stating, “Yeah, I think just the game in general did,” when asked if Santander had aggravated his back during Game 3. He continued, “He was pretty stiff, sore after. Checked in with him this morning and still felt it, so wanted to hold off as long as we could.” This statement underscores the team’s cautious approach in handling player health during the playoffs.

Santander’s journey to the playoffs this year has been marred by injuries and inconsistent play. After signing a lucrative five-year, $92.5 million contract with the Blue Jays last offseason following a standout season with the Orioles, expectations were high. However, his performance fell short, reflected in a -1.0 WAR and limited playoff success, where he managed only 3 for 15 at the plate.

As the Blue Jays gear up for a critical Game 4, fans and analysts alike are left questioning how the team will adjust without one of their key hitters. The urgency to secure a win is palpable, and the stakes have never been higher. With Santander sidelined, all eyes will be on Loperfido and the rest of the roster to step up in this decisive moment.

Stay tuned as we continue to follow this developing story and provide updates on the ALCS and the Blue Jays’ journey in the postseason.