NYC Celebrates Hanukkah Amid Tragedy of Australian Attack

UPDATE: Hanukkah celebrations lit up New York City on the night of December 14, 2025, despite the horrific antisemitic terrorist attack in Australia that claimed 16 lives. The attack, which occurred during the first night of the Jewish holiday, targeted a Jewish gathering on Sydney’s renowned Bondi Beach, sending shockwaves around the world.

In NYC, menorah lighting events proceeded as planned, showcasing resilience and solidarity within the Jewish community. At Grand Army Plaza, the annual Largest Menorah lighting drew attendees who were determined not to let fear overshadow their traditions.

Aly Singhthakur, visiting from Tennessee, expressed her initial hesitation about attending due to safety concerns but ultimately chose to join the celebration. “You cannot let it keep you indoors and keep you from doing the things that you love,” she said, highlighting the importance of showing strength and pride in the face of adversity.

Rebecca Carroll, also at the event, emphasized the historical resilience of the Jewish people. “God tells us all to not live in fear, and he protects his children even when tragedy happens,” she stated, reinforcing the community’s commitment to celebrate despite the dark cloud of violence.

While many gathered to celebrate, some took a more cautious approach. Attendee Sarah mentioned her plan to observe the lighting from the outskirts of the event, prioritizing safety but still wanting to partake in the festivities. “I’m not someone who’s super afraid,” she noted, reflecting a common sentiment among those present.

Sofya Reyfman, who immigrated from Russia 36 years ago, shared her defiance against antisemitism, stating, “I’m not afraid of anything.” She acknowledged the sadness of the Sydney attack but insisted on the necessity of unity during the holiday. “We have to stay and fight and be around the menorah during the holiday,” she added.

The atmosphere at Grand Army Plaza was one of celebration mixed with reflection, as attendees honored the memory of those lost in the attack. Despite the tragic events in Australia, the spirit of Hanukkah — symbolizing resilience and hope — shone brightly throughout the city.

As celebrations continue, the community stands united against hate, vowing to uphold their traditions and values. The message is clear: even in the face of violence, the light of Hanukkah will not be extinguished.

Stay tuned for more updates as this story develops.